Cast of Another Simple Favor – Full List and Where Are Now
The sequel to the 2018 hit A Simple Favor is finally here. Another Simple Favor (2025) brings back Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively along with a slate of familiar faces, but also introduces several new characters and a few notable casting changes. Directed by Paul Feig, the black comedy mystery thriller landed on Prime Video on May 1, 2025, and has already sparked plenty of discussion about its cast, plot, and real-life stories behind the actors.
The film reunites Stephanie Smothers and Emily Nelson on the glamorous island of Capri, Italy, where Emily is about to marry a wealthy Italian businessman. But old secrets, new betrayals, and a murder quickly turn the wedding weekend into a chaotic mystery. Here is exactly who appears in the ensemble, what has changed since the first movie, and the latest real-world updates.
Who Is in the Cast of Another Simple Favor (2025)?
Anna Kendrick, Blake Lively, Henry Golding, Andrew Rannells, Bashir Salahuddin
Allison Janney, Elena Sofia Ricci, Michele Morrone, Alex Newell
Paul Feig
Prime Video, May 1, 2025
- All four main cast members from the first film (Kendrick, Lively, Golding, Rannells) return for the sequel.
- Allison Janney joins as a new character, Aunt Linda McLinden – details of her role are still scarce.
- Joshua Satine takes over the role of Nicky (previously played by Ian Ho in the first film).
- Despite early speculation, Elizabeth Perkins is not confirmed to appear in Another Simple Favor.
- The film is set on the Italian island of Capri and revolves around Emily’s (Blake Lively) wedding.
| Actor | Character | Role Type | Returning? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anna Kendrick | Stephanie Smothers | Lead | Yes |
| Blake Lively | Emily Nelson | Lead | Yes |
| Henry Golding | Sean Townsend | Supporting | Yes |
| Andrew Rannells | Darren | Supporting | Yes |
| Bashir Salahuddin | Detective Summerville | Supporting | Yes |
| Allison Janney | Aunt Linda McLinden | New / Supporting | No (new) |
| Elena Sofia Ricci | TBA | New / Supporting | No (new) |
| Joshua Satine | Nicky | Supporting | Recast |
Is Elizabeth Perkins in Another Simple Favor?
This question has popped up repeatedly since the sequel was announced. Elizabeth Perkins does not appear in A Simple Favor (2018), but her name has surfaced on some fan forums and speculative cast lists. As of May 2025, no official source — including IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, or the studio — lists Elizabeth Perkins among the cast. The People.com article detailing the cast’s real-life loves also makes no mention of her.
Despite occasional mentions online, Elizabeth Perkins has not been officially cast in Another Simple Favor. Her involvement remains unconfirmed.
What Is the Role of Allison Janney in Another Simple Favor?
Allison Janney plays Aunt Linda McLinden, a new character not seen in the first film. According to the People.com synopsis, Aunt Linda is likely part of Emily’s family, but specific plot details have not been disclosed. Janney’s casting adds notable dramatic weight to the ensemble.
Are There Any Other Returning Actors from the First Film?
Yes. Kelly McCormack reprises her role as Stacy, and Bashir Salahuddin returns as Detective Ben Summerville. The child character Nicky, previously played by Ian Ho, is now portrayed by Joshua Satine — a recasting that may signal a time jump or a larger role for the character.
Where Are the Cast of Another Simple Favor Now?
Real-Life Updates
The most concrete real-world news surrounding the cast is the film’s Prime Video release. The marketing campaign has focused heavily on the reunion of Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively. People.com published an article in May 2025 highlighting the real-life partners of several cast members, including Kendrick, Lively, and Rannells. No major personal news — such as engagements or breakups — has been reported beyond that piece.
Did Any Cast Members Change from the First Movie?
The most notable change is the recasting of Nicky. Ian Ho played the role in 2018; Joshua Satine now takes over. Additionally, Jean Smart, who appeared briefly in the original as Margaret McLanden, has been replaced by Elizabeth Perkins — though as stated, Perkins’ presence has not been officially confirmed. Other absent characters from the first film, such as Stephanie’s mother, do not appear in the sequel.
Nearly every major character from A Simple Favor returns, with only minor recasts and a handful of new faces. This keeps the core dynamic intact while expanding the world to Italy.
Who Killed Sean in Another Simple Favor?
Based on available plot summaries, Sean Townsend is found murdered in his hotel room during the wedding weekend. Local police initially write it off as an accident, but circumstances point suspicion at Emily. Stephanie becomes the only witness to the murder and later the prime suspect herself.
The killer’s identity is not definitively confirmed in any official synopsis or review as of May 2025. The film builds mystery around Emily, the new character Matteo Bartolo, and other guests. The studio has not released a full spoiler, so any claims about the culprit remain speculative. Rotten Tomatoes describes the plot as revolving around “luxury, twists, betrayal, and another murder mystery.”
When Is the Trailer for A Simple Favor 2 Coming Out?
- 2018 – Original A Simple Favor released, starring Kendrick, Lively, Golding, and Ho as Nicky.
- 2021–2022 – Paul Feig confirms sequel in development; script written by Jessica Sharzer.
- 2023 – Casting announcements: Allison Janney and Elena Sofia Ricci join; Joshua Satine cast as Nicky.
- 2024 – Principal photography completed in Italy; first official images released.
- Early 2025 – Trailer expected; release date set for Prime Video on May 1, 2025.
- May 2025 – People.com publishes “Meet the Real-Life Loves of the Another Simple Favor Cast”.
No official trailer has been released as of May 2025. The film’s marketing has relied on stills and official descriptions. Fans anticipate a trailer later in 2025, possibly tied to the premiere or a festival appearance.
What Is Confirmed and What Remains Unclear About Another Simple Favor?
| Established Information | Information That Remains Unclear |
|---|---|
| All five returning main actors; addition of Allison Janney and Elena Sofia Ricci; director Paul Feig; location Capri, Italy. | Elizabeth Perkins’ involvement — no official confirmation; her name appears on some fan lists but not in official cast credits. |
| Plot involves a wedding, murder, and betrayal on Capri. | Who killed Sean — not confirmed by studio; may be a major spoiler. |
| Prime Video release on May 1, 2025. | Exact full character descriptions for new additions like Elena Sofia Ricci’s role. |
Why the Cast of Another Simple Favor Matters
The sequel brings back nearly every major character from the first film, preserving the dynamic that made A Simple Favor a cult hit. The addition of Allison Janney adds gravitas and suggests a deeper family mystery. The recasting of Nicky with Joshua Satine indicates a time jump or a more prominent role for the child character. The lack of Elizabeth Perkins – who played a minor role in the original – may disappoint some fans, but the focus remains on Stephanie and Emily. The Italian setting and wedding plot promise high-stakes comedy and drama, similar to the original’s tone.
What Do the Official Sources Say?
“Stephanie Smothers (Anna Kendrick) and Emily Nelson (Blake Lively) reunite on the beautiful island of Capri, Italy, for Emily’s extravagant wedding.”
Rotten Tomatoes synopsis
“The film also stars Andrew Rannells (Darren), Bashir Salahuddin (Detective Summerville), Allison Janney (Aunt Linda McLinden), Elena Sofia Ricci…”
People.com
“Joshua Satine plays Nicky, the son of Blake Lively’s character.”
IMDb full cast page
What’s Next for Another Simple Favor?
The film is now available on Prime Video, having premiered May 1, 2025. Fans can expect more detailed character interviews and behind-the-scenes content in the coming weeks. If you missed the original, you can catch up with our Original A Simple Favor cast and plot recap. For more on the director’s upcoming projects, visit our page on Upcoming movies from Paul Feig.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Cast of Another Simple Favor
Is Elizabeth Perkins in Another Simple Favor?
As of May 2025, Elizabeth Perkins is not listed in the official cast for Another Simple Favor. Her character did not appear in the first film, and there is no confirmation from the studio.
Who plays Nicky in Another Simple Favor?
Joshua Satine portrays Nicky in the sequel. In the original film, Nicky was played by Ian Ho.
Does Andrew Rannells return in Another Simple Favor?
Yes, Andrew Rannells reprises his role as Darren, a friend of Stephanie and Emily.
What is the release date for Another Simple Favor?
The film landed on Prime Video on May 1, 2025.
Is there a trailer for A Simple Favor 2?
No official trailer has been released as of May 2025. Fans are expecting one later in 2025.
Who is Allison Janney playing in Another Simple Favor?
Allison Janney plays Aunt Linda McLinden, a new character. Further details about her role are under wraps.
More related posts
Admiral Contact Number UK – Official Phones and Hours
Lewis Carroll – Real Name, Books, and Controversy
Qatar Airlines – UK Contact, Manage Booking & Baggage Guide
Anti-Bullying Week 2025 – Theme Power for Good and Key Dates
Ercan Ramadan – Age, Family, Net Worth and His Life With Vicky Pattison
Who Won Race Across the World 2025 – Caroline and Tom Bridge Victory
Kill Bill The Whole Bloody Affair – UK Showtimes Guide
Alex De Minaur – Bio, Ranking, Net Worth & 2025 Updates
